Skip to main content

Bohol is still poor: is it good news or bad?

For the last three to five years we were made to believe that Bohol indeed leaped out of the poorest provinces. But a new presentation of NSCB, posted in their website in Feb 2011, showed that Bohol, along with Maguindanao, Masbate, Agusan del Sur, Zambo del Norte, Surigao del Norte, is consistently included in the bottom cluster of provinces in 2003, 2006, and 2009. How come this does not make it to the headlines?

When I posted the above opening statement in Facebook and when I brought it up with my friends, I got different reactions, from the lyrical to the absurd.  Atty. John Titus Vistal of the Provincial Planning and Development Office called me up to say that this was a result of methods revision on the part of NSCB. PRMF Provincial Director Rosalinda Paredes emailed me and other interested parties regarding the need to bring the discussion up to the table again. One friend however, told me that this is good for Bohol as this becomes a justification for project proposals on anti-poverty programs.

Honestly, I feel cheated. In the papers I wrote for the last 2 to 3 years, I couched some of my arguments in the context that Bohol was able to reduce its poverty incidence phenomenally (especially when you consider the time frame of achievement). In several conference presentations, in Belgium, in Ireland, among others, I questioned these achievements and put forth counter arguments....only to realize now that we are still, like the conflict-prone provinces in the South, in the bottom 20 of laggards in terms of poverty reduction achievements.

Consider for example, the table below which I presented in the conference in Singapore;
1997
2000
2003
2006
Sulu
Masbate
Zamboanga del Norte
Tawitawi
Masbate
Sulu
Maguindanao
Zamboanga del Norte
Eastern Samar
Romblon
Masbate
Maguindanao
Ifugao
Ifugao
Surigao del Norte
Apayao
Mt. Province
Lanao del Sur
Agusan del Sur
Surigao del Norte
Lanao del Sur
Sultan Kudarat
Surigao del Sur
Lanao del Sur
Romblon
Maguindanao
Misamis Occidental
Northern Samar
Abra
Tawi-tawi
Mt. Province
Masbate
North Cotabato
Abra
Biliran
Abra
Camarines Norte
Agusan del Sur
Lanao del Norte
Misamis Occidental
Davao Oriental
Mt. Province
Camarines Norte
Agusan del Sur
Northern Samar
Capiz
Kalinga
Occidental Mindoro
Agusan del Sur
Camarines Norte
Sulu
Oriental Mindoro
Antique
Eastern Samar
Sarangani
Sulu
Marinduque
Camiguin
Antique
Kalinga
Surigao Del Norte
Marinduque
Palawan
Surigao del Sur
Surigao Del Sur
Lanao del Norte
Sultan Kudarat
Mountain Province
Camarines Sur
Bohol
Abra
Sarangani
Caraga
Catanduanes
Occidental Mindoro
Lanao del Norte
Siquijor
Zamboanga del Norte
Zamboanga Sibugay
Negros Oriental
Table 1. Ranking of Poorest Provinces in the Country – 1997-2006 (Source: NSCB 2006)
(Red – present in list for 4 periods;  Orange – present in list for 3 periods; Rust – present in list for 2 periods)

In the above table, Bohol only registered a place in one year. But in the recent presentation of NSCB, the figure below surfaces:

  
  Table 2. Poverty Ranking Of Provinces Over time (NSCB 2011)

So what does this tell us?


While it is apparent that there is a revision of methodology, Dr. Virola in his presentation contended that


       "In general, poverty estimates using both the old and refined methodologies showed similar trend/pattern. In terms of levels, estimates based on the old methodology were higher than those of the refined methodology."



Why should we bother?



In a paper I wrote in 2007, I argued the following:



"Despite deficiencies in methodology, poverty statistics in the Philippines has recently become not only as a means of identifying the most deprived regions or provinces and the needed interventions, but also as an evaluation tool of the performance of local government units (LGUs).  Thus, it does not only direct attention to what particular areas of the country require intervention, but it also highlights the ability or the failure of certain LGUs to serve the interests of poor people.  When the NSCB releases provincial poverty statistics and ranking of top twenty poorest provinces, this normally becomes a hot media commodity to which LGU leaders are most sensitive.  Thus, inclusion into what is infamously called as the Club 20 (the term that refers to the twenty poorest provinces of the country), is already a cause of alarm to LGU officials who are concerned of their prominence in the political sphere or the support of their constituents."

Is it a good thing or a bad thing?

I realize that the implications are circular rather than linear.  Also, the data assuming its veracity, may affect different stakeholders in different ways.  But as a province concerned with making our communities progressive and our constituents endowed with capabilities to realize their dreams, this is a cause of worry and concern. 





Comments

Anonymous said…
This does not really do any sense, making Phillipines a progresssive place will make the rest of the places follow. Pointing out to individual provinces would justify nothing since the country is still overall in poverty crisis. Walay mapili although ahead with bohol in terms of infra projects and all but crimes are all over. I would rather stay in the non complicated but peace oriented Bohol.
Anonymous said…
I just now found your illucidating website and am getting hooked. My husband and I are making our way into retiring in Tagbilaran. We hope to venture with the International Deaf Education Association to help in their employment and education projects. My husband is a deaf education specialist currently serving in the DODEA-Pacific, Japan District.
Anonymous said…
I just now found your illucidating website and am getting hooked. My husband and I are making our way into retirement in Bohol. We are planning to venture with the International Deaf Education Association to help in their education and employment projects.
Miko Cañares said…
many thanks. i make it a point to post at least once a month. glad to know that you are planning to spend retirement in the island and contribute to its development. IDEA has several laudable programs and I am a supporter (as a consumer) of their hotel and restaurant.
Unknown said…
Hi Miko,
I just found your blog and it is very impressive with lots of valuable information. About the incidence of poverty in Bohol, I do appreciate that there may be methodological issues but is there not another issue about whether the "poverty line", that is the cutoff for being considered "poor" is too low. It is a good measure to use in comparing to other provinces in the country but does it understate the number of people who are actually"poor"? Is the poverty line a realistic measure of who is poor in the Philippines?
Forrest Malakoff
Miko Cañares said…
Hi Forrest, sorry it took a while for me to respond to the comment. For the last five months I was unable to log on to blogger because (well, well, well) I forgot my password.

You are right in questioning the value of the "line" and for raising an important concern. But first I would like to go back to how it is measured.

Poverty measurement in the Philippines uses the cost of basic needs (CBN) approach), in which poverty lines are calculated to represent the money resources required to meet the basic needs of the household, including an allowance for non-food consumption (NSCB 2005). Basic food requirements are defined using area-specific menus comprising of low-cost food items available locally and satisfying minimal nutrition requirements as determined by the Food and Nutrition Research Institute (currently equivalent to 2000 kilocalories per capita).

To determine the poverty line, a food menu which is representative of both urban and rural areas of the country is constructed and forms the food threshold. The expenditure patterns of households within the ten percentile in the income distribution are then utilized to determine the poverty threshold which is the cost of minimum food and non-food requirements of every household. (Virola and Encarnacion 2003). The poverty threshold is used to compute the poverty incidence which refers to the proportion of families with income less than the poverty threshold to the total number of families in the population. (NCSB 2005)

Therefore, who are in the line and below it, are not the only ones that matter. The vulnerable people a few notches above the line is not rich at all. Which means the information has to be dealt with in caution in terms of gauging overall well-being.

Popular posts from this blog

5 Things To Love about Joseph Gara's Songs

- Full disclaimer here – I am a huge Joseph Gara fan. I saw him for the first time in a wedding party of a dear friend, unmindfully singing as guests were entering the ballroom of a hotel. Apart from his guitar, he was his own prop, tucked neatly at one side of the stage, almost unseen as a massive bouquet of giant white lilies and carnations stood beside his guitar stand.   Right there and then I thought that this guy would go places, because it was quite clear that he liked his music, and while he sang covers of popular acoustic ballads, he seemed to claim them as his own, making the music sound fresh, and the words as if they were freshly minted.   I am an avid spectator of his shows – at South Palms Resort ,   one of our favourite staycation spots in Bohol, where he seemed to be a regular; at the many weddings that he was contracted to serenade; at the many cultural events in the province where he was a part of or was the sole reason for its convening.   I also follow

Bohol opens up further, but are we ready?

March 3 marks the beginning of the Provincial Government of Bohol’s restrained abandonment of strict entry measures to incoming travellers. The lengthy text of the policy that you can find here relaxes the several requirements imposed in prior months regarding travellers entering the province.   Very briefly,   it just means less stringent protocols for visitors and returning residents to allow the economy to recover.         I agree that the economy has suffered significantly.   Our research , even when it only covers the city of Tagbilaran, the provincial capital, indicates that at the height of the implementation of strict community quarantine protocols, at least 5,154 jobs were either temporarily or permanently lost.   Undoubtedly, this figure was higher province-wide.   The visual signs are also evident. If you go to Tawala , that tourism strip in Panglao Island, on a Friday night, the area resembles a ghost town of dark and closed buildings, save for a few establishments which

3 Reasons Why I am Worried about Education During this Pandemic

  The last four weeks or so, we have seen how the delivery of basic education has shifted significantly from face-to-face to a myriad of forms, masked by fancy labels as synchronous (e.g. fully online, virtual classes), blended (e.g. a mix of online and face to face instructions allowed only in specific contexts), and distance modular (e.g. learner-paced learning based on scheduled learning modules, done either through paper or web-based learning management systems). There have been significant apprehensions from different people, including parents such as myself.  Firstly, there is the problem of weak internet connectivity.   We all know that the technological infrastructure is not ready for a fully online learning delivery. There have been serious complaints in the past three years on the inability of telecommunications companies to deliver on their promised connection speed.  Based on statistics, our country has one of the slowest internet speed across the Asia Pacific .  Second, we